# What a program committee looks for in an abstract

Author: Marin Niehues, Stage Starter · Published: 2026-03-27 · Updated: 2026-11-16
Topic: Call for Papers & Submissions (https://stage-starter.com/blog/topic/call-for-papers/)
Source: https://stage-starter.com/blog/what-a-programme-committee-looks-for/

A program committee looks in an abstract for the answer to a single question: does this session belong in our program, and will our audience recognize its own problem in it? The program committee is the group that selects a conference's program from all talk proposals, and it reads under conditions that explain more about the selection than any official criterion. Submissions in the hundreds meet a few evenings of available time, in many cases unpaid alongside a day job. This produces an order of priority: first a submission has to be easy to place, and only then does it become interesting.

**The program committee assesses your submission against the audience it expects and against all other proposals in the same track. In this order of priority your qualifications only come afterwards.**

## Who sits on a program committee, and how does it read?

A program committee is made up of practitioners from the conference's field: in the community sector mostly volunteers with a full-time job, in the commercial sector a program team working to an internal brief from the organizer. They read your abstract, the short description of your session in the submission form, over a weekend or a few evenings, and every single decision then has to be justifiable to the other members.

The first pass sorts out anything that clearly belongs to no track, and it takes one to two minutes per proposal. Whatever survives it is read properly. Placement therefore comes before content, because a text that cannot be assigned to any track drops out of the process before anyone judges its quality. Your proposal is never assessed on its own: it sits alongside dozens of others in the same track, and the program emerges from this ranking.

**The situation at the reading table**
- 50 to 300 texts | are read by a committee per edition
- 1 to 2 minutes | is the time each submission gets in the first pass
- Dozens per track | sit alongside your proposal

What is checked in these minutes is not written in any form. Hardly any organizer could write their criteria down as a list, because they experience the assessment as an overall impression and express it in sentences such as “that fits us” or “we already had that last year”. Stage Starter has therefore translated these unspoken checks into thirteen filters, grouped by content, trust and culture, and checks every submission against them before it goes out. The reviewer counts nothing off; after two minutes they simply have a feeling.

## What criteria does a program committee use to assess submissions?

A program committee assesses submissions by four questions that hardly anyone asks out loud:

1. **Fit:** Does this talk belong in this program, measured against the track logic and the audience profile the organizer expects for this edition?
2. **Audience:** Will the room recognize in this description a problem it knows from its own working life?
3. **Person:** Why this particular person for this slot, and what have they experienced that makes their view valuable?
4. **Marketability:** Does this session fill an entire slot, and can it be explained to the audience in one sentence?

Fit is decided in seconds, and quality and originality are only judged afterwards. Many proposals that are excellent in substance fail at the second question, because they deal with a topic rather than a situation, or because they pitch at the wrong level of experience. A talk on structuring client engagements comes across as patronizing to experienced managing directors if it was written for junior consultants, and remains inaccessible to junior consultants as soon as it is built for partner level.

For the third question, the reviewer is looking for a concrete professional anchor, a role, a project or a turn in a career from which the insight comes. Vague claims of expertise get lost in a pile of two hundred, while a named experience sticks in the memory. The organizer asks the fourth question as the operator of the event, because they will later have to describe your session on the program page, announce it in a newsletter and represent it to sponsors. A proposal that is hard to summarize usually has a central idea that has not yet been worked through.

## What happens when two submissions deal with the same problem?

When two submissions deal with the same problem, the committee compares them against each other and usually takes only one into the program. A committee with three sessions on succession in family businesses then asks whether its audience gets something here that it does not get from the other two.

The angle tips the balance first, because a perspective already circulating in the field loses against a view from outside. Then comes the evidence, because a position tied to a project of your own is stronger than the same statement in general form. Of two equally strong proposals, the one that finally gets into the program is the one the organizer can sell to their audience in one sentence.

This leads to the most uncomfortable feature of the process. A proposal can answer all four questions cleanly and still be rejected because a second one fills the same gap better. Timing works the same way: a topic that was on every stage two years ago is hard to place today, while a topic your field is currently debating that has not yet reached the conference circuit has unusually good chances. Both say little about the quality of your work and a lot about the state of the field. How strongly chance plays a part in such procedures was measured by the machine learning conference NeurIPS in 2014: it had 166 submissions reviewed by two independent committees, and the two disagreed on around a quarter of them.

## What a program committee weighs up across the whole program

At larger conferences a program chair sits above the track committees and is answerable for the coherence of the whole program. This role reads your submission asking whether the program as a whole works with this session in it.

A program has to satisfy several grids at once. The tracks have to be filled, including the unpopular ones. Levels of experience need a mix, so that the attendee with fifteen years of practice finds something just as much as the colleague hearing about the topic for the first time. Six talks in a row in the same format make a conference day heavy going, which is why formats have to vary, and when it comes to names a program needs well-known voices for promotion and new ones so that it does not look the same every year.

For you this shifts the yardstick. Your proposal competes for a specific gap in the grid, which lies somewhere different in every edition. The same submission that is rejected one year because the track already has two similar sessions gets through the next year because neither of those speakers submitted this time. For new speakers this grid works in their favor more often than they assume: as soon as a program's anchor slots are in place, a program chair actively looks for voices their audience has not yet heard.

**You are measured against the other proposals in the same track, and this field of comparison looks different at every conference and in every year.**

## A strong topic in the wrong frame fails before it is assessed

The most common reason for a rejection is a mismatch between topic and frame. A talk on organizational development can be highly relevant to a sales conference, and worded without any recognizable link to sales and sales organization it drops out in the first pass without ever reaching the reviewer who would have recognized its value.

The same mechanism applies to the choice of track. The assignment decides which committee reads your proposal at all and against which audience it is judged. Anyone who picks the wrong track ends up with a committee that has a different audience in mind, and the rejection that follows concerns the assignment. The [process around it](/en/blog/what-is-a-call-for-papers/) with its deadlines and mandatory fields therefore explains only part of the selection.

## What gets read alongside the abstract

Where the committee sees names, an unsure reviewer searches for yours. What appears on the first page of results either confirms the professional identity from your submission or calls it into question. In anonymous review only the text counts in the first pass, and the profile only comes into play in the final selection. An experiment at the computer science conference WSDM 2017 showed that reviewers who could see the names clearly favored submissions from famous authors and prestigious institutions. How a [public presence as a speaker](/en/blog/personal-brand-as-a-speaker/) comes about is therefore part of the submission work, even if it happens months beforehand. The same goes for the bio, which in the process answers the risk question, the organizer's worry about being embarrassed in front of the audience and sponsors by an unknown speaker.

The tone is read as well. Every conference has its own tone of voice, from the loud keynote stage to quiet argument in front of a specialist audience, and the organizer uses your text and your profile to check whether your signals fit. A perspective that is genuinely new in this community often has a stronger effect than yet another qualified insider, and a consultant from a different industry brings this novelty without having to do anything for it.

## What the inside view says about the effort

The picture from the reading table determines where preparation time goes. Placement happens before reading, which is why researching a conference's audience and track logic comes before the first sentence is written. Because every decision is made in comparison with dozens of other proposals, a pattern only becomes visible over many submissions. At this volume of submissions, 5 percent at most lead to an acceptance on the market, while our own submissions for clients reach up to 19 percent per conference, because every submission is built against the committee's questions beforehand.

[Stage Starter](/en/) takes this work off your hands: we find the right calls, write the submission and submit it. The program committee decides on acceptance, and our operation makes sure your submissions stand up in front of it in both volume and fit. How a submission runs from call to acceptance is described in the guide to calls for papers.

**A program committee is looking for a session that clearly belongs in its program, names a problem its audience has and fills a gap in the grid. The assessment is a comparison under time pressure, and anyone who knows the conditions of this comparison reads their rejections differently.**

**Sources**
- Corinna Cortes and Neil D. Lawrence: Inconsistency in Conference Peer Review: Revisiting the 2014 NeurIPS Experiment, preprint on arXiv, 2021
- Andrew Tomkins, Min Zhang and William D. Heavlin: Reviewer bias in single- versus double-blind peer review, journal article in PNAS, 2017
- Alina Beygelzimer, Yann N. Dauphin, Percy Liang and Jennifer Wortman Vaughan: Has the Machine Learning Review Process Become More Arbitrary as the Field Has Grown? The NeurIPS 2021 Consistency Experiment, preprint on arXiv, 2023

How big the trade fair market is as a stage for speakers and how to plan trade fair stages over two years is covered in Speaking at trade fairs.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a program committee, and who sits on it?

A program committee is the group that selects a conference's program from the talk proposals submitted. It is made up of practitioners from the field, mostly volunteers at community conferences and an organizer's program team at commercial ones. Larger conferences have a separate committee for each track and a program chair above them.

### Are submissions reviewed anonymously?

Many community and technology conferences review anonymously in the first pass, so the reviewer only sees the title and abstract. Commercial conferences and association events usually see the name from the start. In both procedures the profile is read in the final selection at the latest.

### What causes most submissions to fail?

Most submissions fail on fit with the program, long before content or quality is checked. A topic that is relevant for this audience but described in the language of another field drops out in the first pass. A second common reason is pitching at the wrong level of experience for the audience.

### Does my list of references count for more than the topic?

The topic counts first, because fit in terms of content is decided before the profile. Your profile then comes into play as reassurance against the risk of a poor booking. On commercial stages references count for more, while in the community sector the text remains dominant.

### How important is the talk title for selection?

The title decides whether a reviewer reads the abstract attentively, because it is the first thing they see in the first pass. A title that makes audience and problem recognizable answers the question of fit before the first sentence. More on this in the article on the [talk title](/en/blog/talk-title-it-sa-forum/).

### How long should an abstract be?

An abstract usually runs to 100 to 300 words, and the submission form sets the upper limit. More important than length is that the first paragraph names the session's audience, problem and outcome. What belongs in an abstract is explained in the article [What is an abstract for a conference?](/en/blog/what-is-a-conference-abstract/).

### Does it help to write to the organizer before submitting?

At large conferences it makes little difference to the assessment, because organizers and committee work separately. At smaller events and associations they are often the same people, and there an earlier presence in the community really does pay off.

### Why is the same submission sometimes accepted and sometimes rejected?

Every conference has a different field of comparison and has to fill a different grid. One year your proposal meets two similar sessions, the next year none. That is why a single decision says little, and only a series of submissions reveals a pattern.

If you want to know how your topics would fare in front of a program committee, talk to us in an [initial consultation](/en/erstgespraech/).
