What is thought leadership in B2B, and what does the stage have to do with it?
Thought leadership refers to a person's publicly held position on an open question in their field, backed by their own work. The German equivalent, Vordenkerschaft, captures the essence, yet nobody in marketing departments uses it. In B2B the term has a concrete function, because decisions on contracts are made there long before a supplier is invited to a meeting. At the same time, it is the most worn-out term in all of B2B marketing, because hundreds of people use it for posts that contain an opinion and nothing else.

Thought leadership refers to a person's publicly held position on an open question in their field, backed by their own work. The German equivalent, Vordenkerschaft, captures the essence, yet nobody in marketing departments uses it. In B2B the term has a concrete function, because decisions on contracts are made there long before a supplier is invited to a meeting. At the same time, it is the most worn-out term in all of B2B marketing, because hundreds of people use it for posts that contain an opinion and nothing else.
What does thought leadership mean, and where does the term come from?
Thought leadership means that a person's view on a specialist topic is quoted in their market, including by people who have never worked with them. The term in its current sense was coined in 1994 by Joel Kurtzman, then editor-in-chief of the business magazine strategy+business, for interviewees with original ideas. In the German-speaking world it has become established via LinkedIn. The assessment of such a person circulates without them having to be in the room.
Three components belong to it. The first is a question that is genuinely open in the field, one that experts argue about. The second is your own answer to it, which differs from the usual one and can be summed up in one sentence. The third is material from your own practice against which this answer can be tested: projects, figures, patterns observed over years.
Without the first part, you are talking about something nobody discusses any more. Without the second, you are repeating the industry consensus in your own words, and whoever leaves out the third has an opinion of the kind found in abundance in every field.
The difference from self-promotion and from advertising
Self-promotion is about you. It tells people what you have achieved, which clients you work with and how your career went. That is legitimate and even necessary when building a profile, but it does not answer any professional question. What a reader takes away from it is that you exist.
Advertising is about your offering. It describes a service with its benefit and its price, and it is aimed at people who are supposed to buy. That too is an honest format, as long as it remains recognizable as such.
A position is about the subject. The most useful test for this is the contradiction test: could an experienced colleague disagree with your statement on solid grounds? If not, you have stated something self-evident. Sentences such as “Trust is crucial in B2B” fail this test, because nobody holds the opposite view.
Why this matters more in B2B than in other markets
A consulting service cannot be tried out before purchase. The buyer decides on something that only comes into being through the collaboration, and usually does not decide alone. Their risk lies less in the money than in their own position, because a project that fails reflects on whoever proposed the supplier.
In this situation, they look for something that lets them form a judgment before they expose themselves. They want to see how someone thinks, where that person's limits lie and whether their view matches what the buyer observes in their own company. A text with a clear thesis gives them that, while a service description sounds the same at every firm.
Then there is the length of the process. From the first point of contact with a consultant to the signed engagement, several weeks pass in B2B, and for extensive projects half a year or more. During this time something of you has to stay in people's minds, and a position has the advantage that it can be passed on in one sentence.
Which formats are there for thought leadership?
There are five common formats for thought leadership, and they differ clearly in effort and lasting effect. As rough rules of thumb, they can be placed like this:
- LinkedIn post: written in twenty minutes, out of sight after a few days, good for presence between larger pieces of work, too short for evidence.
- Specialist article or guest piece in trade media: a few days of work, findable and citable for years.
- Study with original data: weeks to months of effort, picked up by third parties and the longest-lasting.
- Podcast: an hour of conversation plus preparation, in which details and caveats emerge that no text conveys.
- Talk at an industry conference: weeks of preparation, a room full of decision-makers and a recording that keeps working.
An industry conference is a usually one or two-day event at which an industry exchanges knowledge through talks. The talk there occupies a special place in this series, because audience, time and contradiction are present at once and the speaker alone has to answer for it. How a single talk can be turned into posts for LinkedIn and a blog is described in the article How do I turn a conference talk into content.
What a talk does with a position
A text can assert a thesis, whereas a talk has to demonstrate it, because thirty or forty-five minutes cannot be filled with an assertion and the audience expects a development that leads from a starting point to a result. You need cases and figures, along with the point at which your own rule once failed. A room full of experts notices within minutes whether someone is speaking from their own work or from material they have read.
Then there is the Q&A at the end. There, your thesis faces the collective experience of the room, in public, with no time to prepare and in front of people who know the same problems from their own practice. How such a talk is structured so that it can withstand this pressure is described in the article on the structure of a specialist talk.
The third point concerns the selection beforehand. A program committee, meaning the group that decides on the submitted proposals, has weighed your contribution against dozens of others on the same topic. A third party has thus given its verdict before you enter the room. This external confirmation counts for more in the market than anything someone publishes about themselves, and it is the core of what building a personal brand as a speaker achieves.
The way onto such stages leads through the call for papers, the public invitation with which a conference collects talk proposals, and through the abstract, the short description of the planned talk. Stage Starter takes on this work for you: we find the right calls, write the submission and submit it. We develop the talk with you, follow up with the organizers and accompany you all the way to the stage, while your time stays with your position. Working together starts from $999 net per month.
How do you measure the success of thought leadership?
You measure the success of thought leadership by what others do with your position, and reach or interactions say little about that. The first signal is inbound inquiries that refer to your thesis, for instance when a prospect mentions your talk or your article in the first conversation. The second is quotation by third parties, meaning trade media, colleagues or clients who adopt your wording without being asked.
The third signal is invitations. As long as you apply for stages, you are building a position, and once organizers, podcasts or associations approach you of their own accord, it has arrived in the market. A fourth criterion lies in sales: conversations with prospects who already know your view are shorter and end up less often in a price comparison. Which metrics suit conference appearances in detail is described in the article Measuring the success of conference appearances.
Is thought leadership just a buzzword?
As a word, thought leadership has become a buzzword, yet the thing behind it still works in B2B. As soon as a term stands for visibility, it moves into the targets of marketing departments, and there whatever can be measured gets measured: posting frequency, reach, interactions. A position thus turns into a publishing schedule whose concept still contains the original ambition without ever fulfilling it.
This shows in a text pattern everyone knows. A post opens with an apparent provocation, then lists a few observations that have been established knowledge in the industry for years, and ends with an appeal that hurts nobody. It contains no opponent, no price and no risk. Texts like these are now also produced by machine in seconds, and a market that sees a hundred of them every day develops an immunity to them.
The best-known survey in this field comes from Edelman and LinkedIn and is quoted in almost every article on the subject. It questions several thousand decision-makers in several countries every year, Germany included, and essentially confirms what is said here: good expert positions open doors with buyers, while arbitrary content damages the sender's reputation. For a German specialist market with three hundred decision-makers, it does not replace a look at your own market.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between thought leadership and content marketing?
Content marketing is the systematic publication of useful content in order to generate attention for an offering, and thought leadership refers to the position held in such content. You can do content marketing for years without ever taking a position, and in many companies that is the norm.
Do you need a large reach for this?
In narrow specialist markets, thought leadership needs hardly any reach. If three hundred people in Germany decide on your type of project, all that counts is whether those three hundred know your view. A talk in front of forty of them counts for more than ten thousand views of a post on the open web.
How do I start if I have not published anything yet?
You start with the question on which you regularly disagree with your clients or colleagues in your work. This point of friction is the position, it already exists and usually it has simply never been written down.
Does this also work for small consultancies and sole traders?
Yes, and small providers have an advantage of their own: their position depends on one person and does not have to be agreed internally. Large consultancies build their own institutes and publications for this, while sole traders need their work and a stage where the right people are listening.
Are there examples of good thought leadership in B2B?
A well-known example is Clayton Christensen, who in 1997 put forward the thesis of disruptive innovation in “The Innovator's Dilemma” and backed it with data from the disk drive industry. An example from software is HubSpot, whose founders coined the term inbound marketing and set it out in a book in 2009. Both cases have in common that they started with a testable thesis that experts could dispute and disputed for a long time.
Who coined the term thought leadership?
Joel Kurtzman coined the term in its current sense in 1994, as editor-in-chief of the business magazine strategy+business. The German equivalent is Vordenkerschaft, but the English expression has prevailed in everyday use.
Do thought leaders get paid for talks?
Regular talks at industry conferences are usually unpaid, while corporate events in the European market pay newcomers €1,000 to €3,000 and well-known keynote speakers €6,000 to €15,000. For experts with their own offering, a single contract from the audience is worth more than any fee, which is why Stage Starter brings experts onto specialist stages where their clients sit. The ranges in detail are set out in the guide to speaker fees.
What remains of the term
In B2B, people decide on large sums with few reliable points of reference and therefore look for someone whose thinking they can assess, whatever label the term carries in a few years. This leads to two lines of work. One concerns content and consists of sharpening your own position until it fits into one sentence and withstands the disagreement of experienced colleagues without retreating into platitudes. The other is practical and consists of finding places where the right people are listening, and it is regularly underestimated, although it decides the impact of the first.
If you want to know which specialist stages suit your position and your clients, we can work that out in a first conversation.

Marin Niehues is a management consultant and international speaker. With Niehues Consulting he works with organisations from scale-ups to DAX 40 corporations, and on stage he has spoken at more than 45 conferences in 23 countries.
All articles by Marin Niehues


